Carroll Gardens Classic Diner

155 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Order now
Hero image

Open 24 Hours

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Carroll Gardens Classic Diner Reviews on Grubhub

Christina

Top Reviewer
Accidentally left my settings on the wrong address. The delivery person went to the address they received but that was no longer where I physically was at the moment I was at work. He called saying he was outside and when I didn't see him, that's when I realized but he couldn't understand me so he went back to the diner. I had to wait extra long but eventually, they got it to me, so thank you for that.

Sophia

Top Reviewer
2nd time ordering from this place . Today I had the best diner eggs Benedict in a very long time. Food comes fast, intact and exactly as requested. I love this place . Best diner around ! Ps. It’s a rainy morning and it arrived before the scheduled time ����

Vicky T

Top Reviewer
Best effin lemon chicken orzo soup almost as good as my hest friend mom makes on easter.

Brent

1 review
Perfect food to people that need to sober up. Good tasting and very filling.

Chris

Top Reviewer
Best late night food in the neighborhood. Delivery always on time, or early!

Reviews from Seamless.com

Carroll Gardens Classic Diner Reviews on Seamless

Matt

4 reviews
People,reviewing this place negatively are doing so solely on price... I get my orders within 20 minutes, always hot/fresh, & never any mistakes. The food is good diner food, I'm from NJ - diner capital of the world. You see the prices before you order, you don't want to pay, don't order. I'd highly recommend for breakfast or sandwiches...

William

2 reviews
The food here always tastes good and comes quickly, well before the estimate. Not sure why all the bad reviews. My wife and I order here regularly and haven't had to complain yet. This place is great to go to for weekend breakfast as well!

Jerry

Top Reviewer
I love Carroll Gardens Classic Diner!!! Due to work I often have to order late. Whenever I can order from Carroll Gardens it's a treat!!!
Thanks for making amazing sandwiches and soups... and delicious french fries!

IRIS

2 reviews
Ordered the burger medium and it was perfect. The lettuce, onion, and tomato were fresh, seriously one of the better burgers I've had from a diner here in Brooklyn. Fries and onion rings weren't soggy either.

Corey

Top Reviewer
Everything was pretty good, except their "barbecue sauce" they provided tasted like water down ketchup. They'd do better to provide packaged BBQ Sauce as opposed to trying to make their own incorrectly.

About us

Breakfast, Diner, Greek, Salads, Sandwiches
Today
Delivery: 12:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Takeout: 12:00 AM - 12:00 AM