Skip to content

Jump to your usual order:

The Printed Menu

Two Columns. One Counter. Same Recipes Since 1998.

Breakfast is served all day, every day — including weekends. Lunch starts at 11 AM and runs 'til close. Prices include our house bread and butter; coffee refills are free and bottomless.

Chapter I

Breakfast — All Day, Every Day

Two eggs any style served with home fries & choice of toast. Sub fruit or greens +2.

  1. Two Eggs, Any Style $9.50
  2. Buttermilk Pancakes (short stack) $10.25
  3. House-Made Corned Beef Hash & Eggs $15.50
  4. Brooklyn Breakfast Platter $17.95
  5. Western Omelet — Ham, Pepper, Onion $13.75
  6. Eggs Benedict — Hollandaise & English Muffin $14.50
  7. Marinelli's French Toast — Thick-Cut brioche $12.25
  8. Avocado Toast on Brooklyn Sourdough $11.50
  9. Steel-Cut Oatmeal, Brown Sugar & Berries $7.95
Chapter II

Lunch — Served 11 AM 'Til Close

Sandwiches come with a pickle spear & chips. Sub a green side salad +1.50.

  1. Classic Cheeseburger — 8oz hand-formed $14.50
  2. Reuben on Griddled Rye — House Corned Beef $15.75
  3. Grilled Turkey Club — Triple Decker $13.95
  4. BLT with Applewood Smoked Bacon $11.25
  5. Tuna Melt on Sourdough, Swiss & Tomato $12.50
  6. Chicken Pot Pie — Lard Crust, From Scratch $14.95
  7. Hot Open-Face Roast Beef, Mashed Potato Gravy $16.25
  8. Soup of the Day & Half Sandwich $12.95
  9. Cobb Salad — Local Greens, Bacon, Egg, Blue $13.75

All menu items are made to order. Substitutions happily accommodated. Consuming raw or undercooked foods may increase risk — please ask your server.

Today's Specials

Made In-House, Every Morning.

If you've been coming here long enough, you already know these four by name. If you're new — start with the hash.

The Regular's Pick

House-Made Corned Beef Hash

Brined for nine days, hand-chopped every morning, griddled in cast iron until the edges crisp. Served with two eggs any style and our toasted country bread.

$15.50

Fresh-Squeezed Daily

Hand-Squeezed Orange Juice

Squeezed to order from California navels — never from concentrate, never from a bottle. Tall, frosty, and worth the minute you wait.

$5.75

The Batter

Buttermilk Pancakes

Our house batter is mixed from scratch before service — buttermilk, eggs, a whisper of vanilla. Short stack or tall. Maple syrup on the side.

$10.25

Carroll Gardens Original

Brooklyn Breakfast Platter

Two eggs, thick-cut bacon, house-cured ham, griddled tomato, herbed home fries, and one buttermilk pancake. The whole counter in one plate.

$17.95

The Supporting Cast

Sides & Drinks.

Add to any plate, or build a meal around them. Coffee's bottomless — refills are on the house.

Sides

  • Home Fries — herbed, griddled$4.50
  • Toast — rye, sourdough, wheat, brioche$3.25
  • Applewood Bacon (4 strips)$5.75
  • Turkey Sausage (3 links)$5.50
  • One Egg, Any Style$2.75
  • Fresh Fruit Cup — seasonal$5.25
  • Cottage Cheese$4.25
  • Hash Browns, Crispy$4.95

Drinks

  • Brooklyn-Roasted Coffee — bottomless$3.50
  • Hot Tea — Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Mint$3.25
  • Hand-Squeezed Orange Juice$5.75
  • Grapefruit Juice, Fresh$5.25
  • Fountain Soda — Coke, Diet, Ginger, Root Beer$3.50
  • Classic Milkshake — vanilla, chocolate, strawberry$6.95
  • Egg Cream — Brooklyn original$4.50
  • Hot Cocoa with Whipped Cream$4.25

A Note From The Kitchen

“72% of our ingredients come from within 50 miles of this counter. The other 28% come from my mother's recipe box.”

— The Marinelli Family, owners since 1998

Read Our Story Reserve a Table